A Phase 1 Environmental Site Assessment (Phase 1 ESA or Phase I ESA) is a formal due diligence document that identifies potential or existing environmental contamination liabilities at a property. It is conducted in accordance with ASTM International Standard E1527-21, the most recent standard adopted in 2021 and accepted by the U.S. EPA’s All Appropriate Inquiries (AAI) rule.
Critically, a Phase 1 ESA does not involve any soil sampling, groundwater sampling, or laboratory testing. It is a records review and site reconnaissance — its purpose is to identify Recognized Environmental Conditions (RECs) that may indicate the presence or likelihood of contamination. If RECs are identified, the next step is a Phase 2 ESA, which does involve sampling and testing.
In 2019, a commercial real estate investor in Los Angeles closed on a warehouse property without conducting a Phase 1 Environmental Site Assessment. Six months after close, drilling for a planned expansion discovered petroleum contamination from a former dry-cleaning operation — contamination that would cost more than $400,000 to remediate and ultimately rendered the planned development infeasible.
California adds a layer of regulatory complexity beyond the federal AAI framework. CEQA reviews frequently require Phase 1 ESAs as supporting documentation. The California Department of Toxic Substances Control (DTSC) maintains the EnviroStor database of hazardous waste sites — a required part of every Phase 1 database search. The nine Regional Water Quality Control Boards maintain GeoTracker, the state database for underground storage tanks and cleanup cases.
California’s extensive industrial history and strict cleanup standards mean that Phase 1s in California more frequently identify RECs than in other states — and those RECs often lead to Phase 2 investigations.
Phase 1 ESAs are most commonly required by: commercial real estate lenders (virtually all commercial loans over $1 million now require a Phase 1); buyers conducting due diligence before closing on commercial or industrial property; sellers who want documentation of clean conditions; developers applying for certain permits under CEQA; and government agencies acquiring or managing property.
A Phase 1 ESA under ASTM E1527-21 has four components: (1) records review including federal and state environmental databases, historical aerial photographs, fire insurance maps, and regulatory files; (2) site reconnaissance — a physical visit to the property to observe current and past uses, storage areas, staining, distressed vegetation; (3) interviews with current and past owners, operators, and occupants; and (4) a written report identifying RECs, CRECs, and HRECs.
Phase 1 ESA costs in Southern California depend on property size, complexity, prior uses, and turnaround time:
A standard Phase 1 ESA in California typically takes two to four weeks from contract to report delivery. Expedited timelines of 7 to 10 business days are possible for standard properties with appropriate priority fees.
If a Phase 1 ESA identifies RECs, the next step is typically a Phase 2 Environmental Site Assessment — an intrusive investigation involving soil borings, groundwater monitoring wells, and laboratory analysis to determine whether contamination is actually present. If Phase 2 sampling confirms contamination, a remediation plan must be developed and implemented under the oversight of the appropriate regulatory agency.
A Phase 1 ESA is purely a records review and site walkthrough — no samples are collected, no holes are drilled. Its output is a professional opinion about whether environmental conditions exist that may indicate contamination. When the Phase 1 identifies recognized environmental conditions (RECs), the Phase 2 ESA is the investigation that actually tests the soil and groundwater to determine whether contamination is present. Phase 2 scope depends entirely on what the Phase 1 found: a former dry cleaner on the site demands chlorinated solvent sampling at specific depths; a historic gas station requires petroleum hydrocarbon analysis of soil and groundwater at and downgradient of the underground storage tank location.
G3 SoilWorks manages both Phase 1 and Phase 2 investigations as an integrated service — meaning the same team that identifies the RECs designs and executes the Phase 2 investigation, without the handoff delays that occur when separate firms handle each phase.
The Phase 1 ESA report organizes its findings into three categories defined by ASTM E1527-21. A Recognized Environmental Condition (REC) is a condition that indicates the possible presence of hazardous substances or petroleum products on the property and that the EP believes warrants Phase 2 investigation. A Controlled Recognized Environmental Condition (CREC) is a REC that has been addressed to regulatory requirements but with conditions on land use or activities remaining. A Historical Recognized Environmental Condition (HREC) is a former REC that has been addressed to the unrestricted use standard — no conditions remain.
In California, RECs frequently include: the current or former presence of underground storage tanks (gasoline stations, heating oil systems); historical dry-cleaning operations using chlorinated solvents; current or former industrial uses involving hazardous chemicals; proximity to known contaminated sites listed in EnviroStor or GeoTracker that could have impacted the subject property through groundwater migration; and fill of unknown origin (which may contain industrial waste or debris in Southern California’s heavily developed urban areas). Not all RECs trigger Phase 2 investigations — the environmental professional’s judgment about the significance of each REC and its potential impact on the subject property determines whether further investigation is warranted and at what locations and depths.
Not all Phase 1 ESAs are equal. The standard permits significant variation in the depth of records review, the thoroughness of the site reconnaissance, and the analytical quality of the REC evaluation. When selecting an environmental professional (EP) to conduct a Phase 1 ESA in California, verify that the EP meets ASTM E1527-21’s definition of a qualified environmental professional — which requires a combination of education and relevant experience, not just a license. Look for familiarity with California-specific databases including DTSC EnviroStor and RWQCB GeoTracker, both of which are required by California practice but may be unfamiliar to out-of-state practitioners.
For properties with prior industrial use, verify that the Phase 1 provider will conduct a regulatory file review — requesting the physical investigation files from the regulatory agency for any known cases on or adjacent to the site. A Phase 1 that identifies a regulatory case in the database but does not pull the file is missing the most important information about the severity and status of that case. G3 SoilWorks conducts regulatory file reviews as a standard component of Phase 1 investigations in California.
Finally, confirm that the Phase 1 report will explicitly address the user reliance provision of ASTM E1527-21 — which allows the report to be relied upon by parties other than the original client, such as a lender. This provision is typically required by commercial lenders and must be included in the original report or added by amendment.
In California’s complex regulatory and legal environment, the Phase 1 ESA is not optional due diligence — it is the baseline standard for responsible commercial real estate transactions and development. The cost of a Phase 1 ESA is a fraction of the cost of discovering environmental contamination after close.
⟶ Schedule an Environmental Assessment
https://g3soilworks.com/services/environmental-management/
📋 GET A PROPOSAL FOR YOUR PROJECT
https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSdNCkQQ2Ys8-j4eDgKHp_hbwhAajop_4U7SXwEpyFv473-D5A/viewform
Standard Phase 1 ESAs for commercial properties in Southern California typically range from $1,800 to $6,000. Complex properties, expedited timelines, or lender-specific requirements can push costs higher. G3 SoilWorks provides fixed-fee proposals after reviewing the property information.
ASTM E1527-21 requires records review of federal and state environmental databases, a physical site reconnaissance, interviews with current and former owners and occupants, and a written report identifying Recognized Environmental Conditions. California Phase 1s also require review of DTSC EnviroStor and RWQCB GeoTracker databases.
While not legally required for all commercial transactions, virtually every commercial lender requires one as a condition of financing, and experienced attorneys recommend them for all commercial property acquisitions. Purchasing without a Phase 1 ESA exposes buyers to environmental liability they may not be able to recover from the seller after close.
A Phase 2 is triggered when a Phase 1 ESA identifies one or more RECs that require investigation to evaluate the actual presence or absence of contamination.
Standard timelines in California are two to four weeks from contract to report delivery. Expedited timelines of seven to ten business days are possible for standard properties with appropriate priority fees.
Follow, engage, learn. Stop by our blog to see what’s happening at G3SoilWorks.
G3Soilworks – a full service geotechnical/ engineering geologic consulting firm serving clients since 2009 and delivering expert solutions with our highly experienced team and specialized consultants.
G3SoilWorks
350 Fischer Avenue Costa Mesa, CA 92626
Tel. 714.668.5600
E. info@g3soilworks.com